Dog training collars are different from the usual nylon or cotton dog collars you can find in pet stores. A dog training collar is a type of collar that aims to discipline dogs in instances that they are being stubborn or naughty.
Types of Dog Training Collars
Before we go to the best training collars, let us discuss their different types.
Head collars or halters resemble muzzles; however, they are used for a different reason. Head collars work like harnesses, but they’re for the head. This type of collar is excellent if you want to teach your dog to heel and properly walk on a leash. So, how does it work? It works by pulling the head of the dog whenever they pull the leash. When used correctly, it will teach your dog not to pull and can also help with other aspects of training.
Martingale collars are also known as limited slip collars or Greyhound collars. The collar is designed to prevent your dog’s head from slipping out of the collar while they are on a leash. The collar will get tight with the application of tension to the leash. Don’t worry, your dog won’t choke, for it has a stopping mechanism that will prevent the collar from closing on your dog’s neck completely. This type of collar is usually made from nylon and has a variety of sizes and colors you can choose from.
Electronic Collars are also known as remote, shock, or e-collars. These devices work by sending electrical currents of slight pain to the dog. This is the most controversial type of dog training collar. Animal activists don’t recommend the use of this type of collar, because they believe that it can cause psychological issues with dogs.
Bark collars are designed to teach dogs to stop barking. It is recommended if your dog barks nonstop. Some types of bark collars may cause pain to your dog, and some may not.
Break-away collars are excellent for daily use. It comes with a safety feature that does not allow choking. You can also use this collar while your dog is on a leash. If the loop of the collar gets caught on something and the dog continues to pull, the collar will break away.
Chain Slip Collars
Chain slip collars are often called choke chains. This type of collar is for training purposes only. This collar is helpful when training your dog to heel and walk on a leash. A quick tug on the leash is done to correct the dog; doing this will cause the collar to somewhat close on the neck of the dog. However, several trainers have eliminated the use of this type of collar because it can damage the dog’s neck if not used properly.
It should always be used with caution. You should never leave the collar on your dog unattended because of the risk of strangulation.
Metal Prong Collars
Metal prong collars may have a harsh look to it, bit several trainers find them effective for stubborn and strong dogs that pull on the leash. They are also known as pinch collars and are designed for correction while in training. This type of collar must be used properly and with caution. Never leave it on your dog when unattended.
The XX Best Dog Training Collars
Now, let’s go to the reason why you are reading this article: the best dog training collars.
1. TBI Pro Dog Training Collar
This training collar is perfect for any sized dog and weight from 10 to 100 pounds. You are able to control whether the device will emit a shock or a vibration, and how strong they will be. The vibration and shock power range from 1-100 levels. You can opt for a gentle level as a reminder for the dog’s first offense and make it a little stronger for repetitive behaviors. You can use the beep mode in improving your dog’s walking and leash training. You can use vibration mode in correcting disobedience and excessive barking.
The remote has a range of 1,600 feet, which gives you plenty of change to control your dog from as far as you can see them. It will take 2 to 3 hours for the battery to fully charge, and it will last up to 20 days. It’s a pretty low maintenance collar. It is on the more expensive side, but with its features, it’s worth it.
It has an ergonomic design, comfortable to hold, and easy to control because of its large separate buttons.
This device was developed with K-9 experts. They were tested on dogs of various temperaments and breeds in partnership with professional K-9 trainers. It is guaranteed to work in a humane way and won’t harm the psyche of your dog.
- LED screen remote
- 1,600 feet range
- Shocks and vibrates, with power levels of 1-100
2. DOG CARE Dog Training Collar
This device has a range of a thousand feet, so as long as you see your dog, you are able to correct them. It is easy to use and it is recommended for first-time dog owners, as well. It is 100% waterproof, so you won’t have to worry if your dog tends to get into things or gets caught in the rain.
There are three deterrent modes available in this device: vibration, shock, and beep. You can control the intensity or power of each mode, as well. It also comes with a security keypad lock that will prevent you from accidentally shocking your dog.
The device also supports a maximum of 3 dog training with 1 remote transmitter. This will be the perfect option if you have more than 2 dogs in your home.
- Modes: vibration, shock, and beep
- Has a range of 1000 feet
- Provides a one-year warranty
- Security keypad lock to prevent accidental shocks
3. Mockins Rainproof Rechargeable Electronic Remote Dog Training Shock Collar
If you are looking for a budget-friendly dog training collar, then the Mockins rainproof rechargeable remote dog training shock collar is for you. It fits dogs from 15 pounds and up. It also offers 100 levels of static shock and vibration, and the delivery is preceded by a warning tone. The collar and remote are also fully rechargeable and waterproof.
The collar can be adjusted from 2 to 22 inches, perfect for small to large dogs. This device will help with walking leash, bark control, obedience training, and more. It has a range of 330 yards, so you can train your dog easily in the back yard or park.
- Has a range of 330 yards
- Perfect for small to large dogs with adjustable collar
- Has 100 levels of vibration and static shock
4. Educator E-Collar Remote Dog Training Collar
The Educator e-collar remote control dog training collar is excellent for owners and trainers who want an excellent substitute for traditional shock collars. Instead of relying on a sharp static shock, it uses blunt stimulation technology that would feel more like a strong tap for your dog. It will be less stressful for your dog but just as effective to make them comply.
The device comes with a Pavlovian Tone feature, where your dog can learn to respond to the sound that comes before the stimulation, rather than the actual stimulation. It also comes with a stop-watch style controller that is also ergonomic, which can also control a tracking light, which will make your dog visible even after dark.
- Ergonomic design
- Has a ½ mile range
- Uses a tapping sensation instead of shock
- Has stimulation levels of 1 to 100
- Comes with lithium-polymer rechargeable batteries and takes 2 hours to charge fully
- Pavlovian tone
- Shock resistant
- Tracking light
5. Wolfwill Humane No-Shock Remote Dog Training Collar
Some trainers choose not to use shock collars because they are worried that it might cause their dog pain. The Wolfwill humane no-shock remote dog training collar uses vibration and tones to give feedback to your dog and is highly effective. The vibration option has 16 levels of intensity. The collar has a range of 660 yards. The touch-distinguished buttons of the transmitter are designed with blind users in mind, although the product is not specific to seeing-eye dog owners.
The collar does an excellent job of getting dogs to stop chasing smaller animals, jumping on tables, and showing various behavioral problems. The device is waterproof, so there is no need to worry about your dog getting into something wet. The lithium battery can be fully charged for two hours and can last for a long time.
- Touch distinguished button design
- Has three modes: tone, vibration, and light
- Comes with adjustable strap
6. Sportdog Brand Fieldtrainer 425
The Sportdog brand fieldtrainer 425 is considered an excellent dog training collar because of its 500-yard range. It can fit dogs from 8 pounds or larger. It comes with 7 levels of intensity that enables you to control the stimulation that your dog receives.
The collar receiver and remote transmitter have DryTek technology feature that makes the device waterproof and can be submerged up to 25 feet. Its rechargeable lithium-ion batteries can be fully charged in two hours. The remote transmitter button functions are customizable, as well. It comes with a detailed operating guide, a training DVD, and a customer care center that is locally based.
The collar can be used in the field with cold heat, snow, rain, dust, wind, and mud.
- Has Drytek waterproof technology and can be submerged up to 25 feet
- Has a range of 500 yards
- Rechargeable battery
- Has three modes: static, tone and vibration
- Supports training up to three dogs
- Neck sizes from 5 to 22 inches
- Long battery life (50-70 hours per charge)
7. Dogtra 1900S ¾ Mile Range 1 Dog Training Collar System
Hailed as one of the most comfortable dog training collars available in the market, the Dogtra 1900S ¾ mile range 1 dog training collar system is a must-have. It is made of 95% polyester and 5% nylon that gives its soft texture that is undoubtedly comfortable on your dog’s skin. It comes with a highly accurate stimulation of 0 to 127.
If your dog loves to swim, this is the perfect collar because it is designed to be completely waterproof. It comes with a seamless and ergonomic design that will wrap around your dog’s neck perfectly. The device is also IPX9K waterproof certified, which means it passed the International Protection Marking system. It can withstand a high-pressure close-range liquid spray for four angles (temperature of 176 degrees F and pressure of 80-100 bars).
It also comes with three different modes: Nick (quick ½ to 1 second), constant stimulation up to 12 seconds, and HPP that offers clear vibration.
- Can fit dogs up to 35 pounds
- Has very precise stimulation
- Waterproof construction
- Made from soft fabric
8. Garmin Delta XC Bundle
The Garmin Delta XC comes with eighteen different levels of stimulation and all of them with varying degrees of intensity. It provides a range of ½ miles and also comes with three configuration or training styles for different behavior problems. The training levels have their own respective buttons.
The device has a waterproof rating of IPX71, as well.
- Short and long adjustable contact points
- LCS display monitor
- High durability
- Three training style settings
- An intuitive 3-button handheld controller
- Supports training up to three dogs
- IPX71 waterproof rating
9. Meyoung Dog Training Collar
The Meyoung dog training collar is the one for you if you live in an area with lots of unfenced acreages. The device can work up to a distance of 2,600 feet or about half a mile. It is also an awesome choice for dogs that bark a lot since the owner can deliver the signal whenever they hear their dog barking, even though they are far away to see.
The device comes with three modes: vibration, beep, and static shock. Most owners use the vibration mode. It can fit dogs weighing from six up to a hundred pounds, and it’s waterproof, as well. The collar is ideal for those who live on big properties. Some would use it to prevent their dogs from going into prohibited areas.
- 2,600-feet range
- IPX7 waterproof and can work well 6-feet underwater
- Long-lasting battery
- Has three modes: vibration, beep, and static shock
- For dogs 6 to 100 pounds
10. PetSafe Gentle Leader Head Collar
If it always feels like your dog is walking you, instead of you walking your dog, then you might need the PetSafe gentle leader head collar. It is an effective but simple way to train your dog walking. The idea of this collar is pretty simple: loop the lead around the muzzle of your dog. A light tug will remind them not to pull away, jump, lunge, or misbehave. There will be no pressure on your dog’s head or throat – just a redirection of their attention that is gentle.
The Petsafe Gentle Leader head collar comes in sizes that are suitable for dogs 5 to over 130 pounds. It also comes in various colors. The package also comes with an explainer DVD that shows the proper way to use the collar.
- Quick and easy to fit
- Comfortable fit
- Straps are made from supple nylon
- Fully adjustable
11. PetSafe Yard & Park Add-A-Dog Collar
PetSafe is a well-known brand when it comes to dog collars. Their Yard & Park Add-a-Dog Collar offers a 400-yard range and eight adjustable levels at two intensity levels. It is waterproof, and you can train three dogs at one time with one remote controller.
The device fits dogs over 8 pounds and great for dogs of all sizes. It also fits neck sizes up to 28 inches. If you are having problems with the device or have any questions when it comes to operating it, PetSafe has a US=based customer care specialists available 6 days a week.
PetSafe is also known for developing static shock technology that has low-output static signals that are fair to dogs yet effective.
- 400-yard range
- US customer care
12. A+ TRAINERROOPZ Dog Training Collar with Remote
The 12. A+ TRAINERROOPZ Dog Training Collar with Remote features, vibration, beep, and shock modes and has various levels for each. You are allowed to control the intensity of every mode. It comes with a long-lasting battery, and you won’t have to worry about running out of battery while training your dog.
The collar offers a range of 800 yards and is suitable for dogs weighing 15 to 120 pounds. You can adjust the collar to your desired size. With the unit’s mini size, your dog won’t be bothered even if you use it on them for more extended periods.
It is IPX6 waterproof. However, you should take the collar off when your dog goes swimming. The collar can be used to correct leash training, barking, walking, aggression, sitting and other behavioral obedience.
- 1000-feet remote control range
- Three training modes: beep, vibration, and shock
- IPX6 waterproof
- Adjustable collar
- Long-lasting battery life
13. Petrainer PET998DRB Rainproof Dog Shock Collar
Petrainer designs its products with the common household dog in mind. Their PET998DRB Rainproof Dog Shock Collar offers a 330-yard range. It comes with 100 levels of stimulation and adjustable collar from size 15 to 22 inches. This collar is best utilized for basic dog training, hunting, barking, aggression, digging, bolting, and jumping.
The collar comes with three safe and humane corrective stimulation modes: vibration, shock, and beep. Training your dog in the rain is not a problem with this product because it is rainproof.
- Has a range of 330 yards
- Zero skin irritation because of silicone covers on contact points
- Rainproof receiver
- Three training modes: static shock, vibration, and beep/tone
14. Banne Dog Training Collar
The Banne Dog Training Collar is best for medium to large dogs. It can be used for dogs weighing around 22 to 88 lbs. The collar will allow you to set the level of intensity of simulated shocks using 16 different options, and it offers a 650-yard range.
The collar is adjustable and can fit neck sizes from 9 to 25 inches. It also features a fast-charging battery, and the receiver is waterproof.
- Fully charged battery can last up to 15 days
- Has a range of 650 yards
- Fast charging battery
15. Casfuy Bark Collar
If your dog is always barking excessively, the Casfuy bark collar is a perfect choice. It has three modes of training: beep, vibration, and shock. It comes with seven shock intensity options, as well. The shock it emits is milder compared to other training collars, which ensured that your dog is not punished too much when they are barking excessively. Instead, they will feel a gentler shock or even not shock at all if you choose other modes.
The device also comes with a smart bark detection chip. It detects vibrations along the collar instead of sound. Chips that detect through sound often mistake other sounds as barks, so it tends to confuse the dog.
You can fit the collar to even small dogs, like puppies, because of its low weight requirement of 8 lbs.
- Offers three modes: shock, vibration, and beep
- Smart bark detection chip
- Can fit dogs weighing 8 pounds and up
- Rechargeable battery
16. iPets Waterproof and Rechargeable Dog Shock Collar
The iPets Dog Shock Collar comes with three modes (shock, vibration, and beep) and 100 intensity options. The remote has different buttons that correspond to different training modes. As a result, there will be fewer tendencies that you will set off another mode by accident.
It offers a range of 300 yards, and the transmitter has no issue sending signals at maximum range. You can use the collar on dogs that weigh up to a hundred pounds.
- Each mode has its own button
- Has a range of 300 yards
- Ergonomically built dial
- Adjustable collar
- Dual rapid charge capacity
How to Choose the Best Training Collar for Your Dog
Stimulation modes / Intensity
This is one of the most important factors to consider when purchasing a dog collar. The intensity of the collar is determined by the stimulation mode. More stimulation modes mean more control over the intensity.
There are three primary stimulation modes most collars have are momentary, continuous, and warning.
- The momentary mode will send one short shock.
- The continuous mode will shock the dog continuously.
- The warning mode will warn the dog by ringing or vibrating before the shock.
Other training collars come with more advanced features and modes. Some features run and point modes, which allows you to hear what your dog does in the walkie-talkie. Think of what you need for your dog and decide on the stimulation modes that will be helpful with your training.
The range determines how far you are able to reach your dog with the device. The typical range of dog collars is around ½ to one mile. Choosing the distance range will depend on how far your dog is allowed to roam without supervision.
The collar size will depend on your dog’s neck size. To measure the collar size correctly, try the collar on your dog and insert two fingers inside. If your two fingers fit perfectly between the collar and the neck, it is the right size.
You can measure the size and make it your basis when you buy a dog training collar. This factor will determine if your dog is comfortable or not.
Price and Brand
Cheaper dog training collars might not have many level options and might hurt your dog too much. It is always best to purchase products from well-known brands, so the safety of your dog is assured.
You also have to consider the material used for the collar because it plays a crucial role when it comes to your dog’s comfort. Most collars are made of nylon, but some are made of leather. Nylon is typically the first choice for dog owners; however, some dogs don’t like the feel of nylon collars on them.
Are shock collars really safe?
Shock collars have become a subject of controversy in the dog training world. Studies have shown that it can affect a dog’s psyche. However, many dog training collar makers have vastly improved the features of their products to make it more humane. There are also other modes you can use instead of the shock option.
Despite the opposition of some people with the use of collars, some owners still choose this option because they find it effective. If you are planning on using dog training collars for your pooch, you can consider the products listed above. They already have a reputation for safety and quality products.